Choose the Right Roofing Material For Your Home’s Stability

Choose the Right Roofing Material For Your Home’s Stability


Choosing the right roofing material is more than just about looks. Your roof plays a huge part in your home’s appeal and functionality. The type of material you pick affects not only the cost and lifespan of your roof but also how your home feels and functions. It’s one of the biggest decisions you’ll make for your home, second to choosing the right roofing contractor. 

To help you make the best choice for your Nashville home, the experts at Tim Leeper Roofing have outlined seven key factors to consider when selecting roofing material for your roof replacement project.

Unsure About the Best Roofing Material for Your Project?

Let Tim Leeper’s Expert Roofers Guide You

Connect with Us Today!

7 Key Factors For Choosing The Right Roofing Material

Roof Slope

One of the first and most crucial factors to consider when selecting roofing materials is the slope of the roof, commonly referred to as the “pitch.” The pitch of a roof is essentially its angle, calculated as a ratio of its vertical rise to its horizontal span, usually measured over 12 inches or feet.

Low Slope Roofs (Pitch of 2:12 or Lower)

Roofs with a pitch of 2:12 or lower fall into the category of low-slope roofs. This shallow pitch presents unique challenges, particularly in water drainage. Unlike steeper roofs, where water naturally runs off quickly, low-slope roofs require materials that can handle potential water pooling, as they do not facilitate rapid water runoff. Traditional materials used for higher slopes, such as standard shingles, are unsuitable for these types of roofs. 

High Slope Roofs (Steeper Pitches)

Conversely, high-slope roofs with a steeper pitch are excellent at draining water and snow. Their steep angle aids in quick runoff, preventing water accumulation and the potential issues it can cause. 

Materials like asphalt shingles or slate tiles are ideal for these types of roofs. They handle the rapid flow of water and snow efficiently and add aesthetic appeal to the structure. However, it’s higher slope roofs might limit headroom in attics or upper stories.

Shallow Roofs

In the middle of the spectrum lie roofs with a shallow pitch, which require a balance between aesthetics and functionality. While they may not drain as effectively as steeper roofs, they offer a visually appealing profile and more interior space. 

Selecting materials for these roofs involves carefully considering their drainage capabilities, aesthetic value, and the additional interior space they provide. 

Roof replacement service providers also play a key role in this selection process. By consulting with these experts, homeowners can make an informed decision that aligns with their practical needs and stylistic preferences.

Overall Cost

Cost is one of the most significant factors in any roof replacement project. While it’s inevitable that replacing a roof will be a substantial financial investment, the choice of roofing material greatly influences the overall expense. It’s essential to start with a clear budget, as this will determine which materials are feasible options and which are beyond financial reach.

However, remember that the most expensive materials sometimes have a different quality or suitability for your specific needs.

Affordable Options

For those with a more limited budget, asphalt shingles, particularly architectural ones, offer an affordable yet reliable solution. They are popular in many areas, including Nashville, due to their cost-effectiveness and decent performance.

Mid to High-End Options

Homeowners with a larger budget might consider more premium roofing systems that offer additional benefits like enhanced durability, aesthetic appeal, or better energy efficiency. For instance, upgrading to luxury asphalt shingles can approximately double the cost compared to standard architectural shingles. Similarly, opting for a standing seam metal roof can triple the price but offers advantages like longevity and a unique aesthetic.

High-End Options

At the top end of the price spectrum are composite (synthetic) shingles, cedar shakes, and slate tiles. These roofing systems represent a significant investment, often outside the average homeowner’s budget. They are known for their exceptional quality, durability, and distinct appearance but come with a much higher cost.

The key factor here is finding the right roofing material that aligns with your budget without stretching your pockets, while ensuring lasting value and protection for your home against the elements.

Roof Lifespan

The longevity of your roof not only affects its value over time but also dictates how soon you might need to plan for another replacement.

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles, available in three types, generally offer a lifespan of 20-30 years, depending on the specific product chosen. They are a popular option for their balance of cost and durability.

Composite and Metal Roofs

For greater durability, consider composite (synthetic) shingles (40-50 years) or standing seam metal roofs (around 50 years). These materials are designed for longevity and can withstand various environmental conditions.

Slate Roofs

If maximum lifespan is a priority, slate roofs are unparalleled, lasting 75 to 100 years. Their durability makes them an excellent long-term investment.

Remember, the lifespan of your roof depends not just on the material but also on good installation and regular upkeep. If you choose quality materials and hire a reputable roofing company in Nashville, your roof will likely last to its maximum lifespan.

Local Climatic Conditions

Different materials are better suited to certain environmental conditions, and choosing wisely can prevent premature wear and damage.

Rain and Snow

In areas with heavy rainfall or snow, selecting materials that can withstand these conditions is key. A sloping roof design is also important for efficient water and snow drainage.

Humidity and Coastal Climates

The risk of mould, mildew, and algae growth is a consideration for homes in humid, coastal areas or near tall trees. Opt for materials resistant to such growth to maintain the integrity and appearance of your roof.

Heat Resistance

Materials like terracotta, slate tiles, and concrete are advantageous in hotter climates. They are designed to withstand high temperatures and provide better insulation, reducing cooling costs. In addition to these considerations, local roof replacement services can help you pick the right roofing material for your home’s needs, suiting the weather conditions.

Curb Appeal

The roofing material you select enhances your home’s curb appeal. Each material offers a unique aesthetic impact, and it’s crucial to consider how much you value this aspect when deciding.

Versatile and Common

Architectural asphalt shingle roofs, widely used nationwide, offer a pleasing aesthetic with various types, styles, textures, and colours. They can easily blend with your neighbourhood’s architectural style or highlight your home’s unique features. However, their widespread use might not make your home stand out in your community.

Upgraded Options for Extra Appeal

If curb appeal is a significant factor in your decision, consider more distinctive options like luxury asphalt shingles or standing seam metal roofs. These materials can add a unique touch to your home’s exterior. Incorporating metal accents with asphalt shingles can also enhance your roof’s visual appeal subtly yet effectively.

Aesthetic Choices

For those seeking the most visually striking options, composite (synthetic) roofs, cedar shake roofs, or slate roofs are excellent. These materials are known for creating some of the most beautiful roofs on the market, offering elegance and a distinct character.

While exploring roofing options, as a homeowner, you have the liberty to choose from a variety of colours and finishes. This allows you to find a roofing material that suits your taste and enhances your home’s overall style. 

However, it’s important to balance your preferences and your neighbourhood’s architectural feel to create a cohesive and attractive look.

Maintenance Requirements

Maintenance Requirements

The level of maintenance your roof requires depends on the material you choose, and it’s important to consider how much time and effort you’re willing to invest in upkeep.

Maintenance for Different Materials

  • Asphalt Shingles: Whether you opt for basic or high-end asphalt shingles, an annual inspection by a qualified roofing company is crucial, especially in areas like Nashville. 
  • Composite (Synthetic) Shingles and Cedar Shakes: Given these materials’ premium investment, they also necessitate regular maintenance. Annual or biannual inspections are recommended to ensure they remain in top condition.
  • Metal Roofing: A popular choice for those with a busy lifestyle, metal roofing requires less maintenance. However, even with their durability, it’s wise to schedule yearly inspections as a precautionary measure to safeguard your investment.

So, no matter the material you choose, routine roof maintenance is key to maximizing your roof’s lifespan. 

Material Warranty

Typically, you’ll encounter two types of warranties: one for the roofing materials and another for the contractor’s workmanship.

The warranty for your roofing material depends on what you choose and is given by the manufacturer. On the other hand, the workmanship warranty, which covers the quality of installation, is provided by your roofing contractor and varies based on who you hire.

Warranties on Different Materials

  • Asphalt Shingles: All types come with a manufacturer’s warranty. Standard options usually offer a 25 to 30-year prorated warranty, while architectural and luxury shingles may offer an enhanced 50-year non-prorated warranty.
  • Steel Standing Seam Metal Roof: Typically comes with a 30-year warranty.
  • Composite (Synthetic) Shingles: Often accompanied by a lifetime limited material warranty, which becomes prorated after a certain period. The exact terms depend on the manufacturer.
  • Natural Materials (Cedar Shake or Slate): These do not usually come with a manufacturer’s warranty due to their natural occurrence. In such cases, the workmanship warranty from your roofing contractor becomes even more significant.

Material warranties can offer peace of mind, assuring you of the quality and durability of your chosen roofing material. However, these warranties’ actual length and coverage vary, making it important to thoroughly understand them before deciding. 

Unsure About the Right Roofing Material for Your Home?

Now that you’re familiar with six key factors to consider for your roof replacement, you’re on your way to making an informed decision. However, understanding these factors is just the beginning. The best choice for your specific needs might still be unclear.

What’s the next step?

Simplify your decision-making process by consulting with the professionals at Tim Leeper Roofing. Our roof repair & replacement in Nashville have assisted numerous homeowners in restoring their roofs to pristine condition. Whether it’s emergency repairs or a complete roof replacement, our team is equipped to handle it all.

Don’t hesitate to reach out. Discuss your roofing project with our experts and receive a free estimate today!


Related Post

Introduction: As we begin another year, it’s an opportune time to reflect on the past and plan for a better future. Many of us set resolutions to improve ourselves, but what about our homes? Are we giving them the attention they deserve? Upgrading appliances and creating new garden areas are great ways to enhance your […]